New argument-BOR, CFNYC version or TKAA version?

[Sroundtable@aol.com]

I may be blaspheming here, but I have listened to both versions several 
times, and though the TKAA version is awesome and actually renewed my energy 
for BOR after hearing it for the first time when i was sort of sick of it, 
the CFNYC version is better.  Roger's voice- though strained on the first few 
lines, warms up nicely and sounds almost vintage the rest of the way.  The 
"OOOOOOh, sally take my hand" sounded like he was 25 yrs old and his scream 
on "They're all wasted" was excellent, IMO.  Pete's guitar work is better in 
NYC and his "Don't cry..." was pure.  Roger's harmonica work is actually WAY 
better in NYC than TKAA.  Zak can't be Keith, but the drum work was very, 
very good in NYC.  Opinions?

Kevin Mc