Re: Who-Salad

["Scott Schrade" <schrade@akrobiz.com>]

> I knew that Roger had sung off-key originally and that his voice is
> overdubbed for the Deluxe edition.  I've heard some people here say that
> they are really bothered by this and I was prepared to get a sort of 'Benny
> Hill female-stunt-woman' presentation (a cigar for anyone catching that
> reference).  I was very suprised to hear that the overdub is very well done;
> seamless.  My question is, does anyone know where that sound bite came from
> that was used?  I seriously doubt that Roger did it for the release within
> the last year or so.  My guess is it was taken from another recording FROM
> that period.  Any thoughts?


No, I think he re-did the vocals last year.  Really.  I thought it was an obvious
"older" Roger vocal sound.  

On this point I think they should've let it alone & went with the off-key vocals.
They weren't *that* bad.


- SCHRADE in Akron