Re: Roger Waters - second fiddle to Gilmour?

[JimboWHO@aol.com]

<< >Roger was never the best songwriter of that band and 
>yet he gets by with a Tommy ripoff (the Wall) and other mindless 
>compositions.
 
WHAT???
Some of those those "mindless" compostitions include:
Money
Us and Them (w/Wright)
Breathe In The Air (w/Gimour, Wright)
Brain Damage
Eclipse
Welcome To The Machine
Have A Cigar
Wish You Were Here
Shine On You Crazy Diamond (w/Gilmour, Wright)

Virtually ALL  of "Animals"

And the vast majority of the aforementioned insignificant little thing call
"The Wall."

Waters was most definitely the best songwriter in the band. Arrogant and
overbearing too but more instrumental in building what Gilmour now considers
his - Pink Floyd.

JJM