Re: Who on DVD

[p47paul@impop.bellatlantic.net]

I am not sure how that is possible.  When Moonie is playing that solo you can see Daltrey and Townshend when he is
finishing with the snare right before the scream.  I am a drummer and there didn't seem to be any overdubbing in
the movie.

Brian Cady wrote:

> Scott Schrade wrote:
> >Moonie's drum solo parts before Roger screams are different
> > on the movie & soundtrack as well !!  Listen closely to the snare drum !!  I wonder why all the tinkering ? !
>
> Moon's drum solo was actually filmed after the Shepperton show.  Keith played
> drums for at least an hour by himself as he was repeatedly filmed.  However, his
> performance was judged substandard for his big film moment and he was called in
> later to overdub his drum part (probably the last drumming he ever did).  The
> version in TKAA has some of the overdubs.  I haven't checked Who's Better Who's
> Best lately but I think it may feature the drum solo without the overdubs.
>
> I'm afraid there is a good bit of artifice to the filmed performance of Won't
> Get Fooled Again, but it is less than most rock concert movies such as the
> excellent but heavily tinkered-with "Stop Making Sense."
>
>                 -Brian in Atlanta