final Beatles/Who comments

["Nicole C." <beatlegirl_13@hotmail.com>]

Kevin Mc:

I'm not trying to blast your opinions at all, you're entitled to them. I 
understand that you respect the Who; I respect them too.  Neither of us 
would be here if we didn't. I just don't understand how you can make 
statements like this:

"tommy was still a real career risk and an original concept and sgt pepper's 
not."

I can't agree with you on that at all. And "I Am the Walrus" is NOT a 
terrible song.

"however, i get really tired of beatles fans who give the who no respect.  a 
beatles fan once told me that the Who were nothing more than a great live 
act.  i wanted to hit him.  beatles fans (too many of them) can't give props 
to any other band or artist and that ticked me off."

Well that guy/girl was right about one thing: the Who ARE a great live act. 
He/she was wrong that that's all they are, but let's not make 
generalizations about ALL Beatles fans based on the ignorance of one.
I'm a big Beatles fan, but obviously I am also here on a Who list. I listen 
to many bands besides the Beatles. One bad apple does not make the entire 
bunch.


From: TJLY99@aol.com
Subject: Re: TO: Nicole regarding the Beatles

"i'm not nicole but.."

Well I am Nicole, and thanks for having my back in this discussion. :)


From: AnEnglishBoy <campbell@fix.net>
Subject: Re: correction on Sgt pepper's- sorry

"That is one of the largest pieces of bullshit I have ever read, regarding 
TheBeaTles and Sgt. Pepper's.
Had to have been spoken by one too young to have lived the moments and seen 
it all come down."

Thank you! Although I also am too young to have lived the moments, but I 
recognize them when I see/hear them.


Anyways, this isn't a Beatles list, and we could argue this forever without 
ever agreeing, so how about we just end it now? Kevin Mc, I guess we'll just 
have to agree to disagree on this one. Coo Coo Cachoo. :)

Who content: I need advice from the boot owners on this list. Is "Shaking 
All Over" a good buy? I found it at my local record store and I wanted to 
buy it but was afraid of getting ripped off since they aren't returnable. So 
if anyone owns "Shaking All Over" (which I believe was recorded at the 
Fillmore East) could you let me know? Thanks!

Nicole


_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp