Healthy discussion



Jim M nakedi at comcast.net
Thu Nov 2 13:00:11 CST 2006


> >Namely: In the Ether
>
> Me too.  Although, it's starting to grow on me...a bit.  I've learned
> that the voice is what is distracting me.  When I listen to the *song*
> and *words*, it's really a fine piece of art.
> I'm sure most press reviewers are also distracted by the first
> impression of the voice Pete used.

I think Roger could have sung this in his natural, gruff tone and it would
have sounded great.  His reaction to the demo made it sound like Pete wanted
him to sing it as Pete did.  It's a shame, Roger really shines on some of
the other slower songs.

> >Trilby's Piano
>
> Who (or what?) the hell is Tribly, and why is Pete excited by
> him??????????

Trilby and Hymie are two older relatives of the kids in Glass Household.
They fall in love against the objections of their families and the kids do a
play about it (Trilby's Piano).

> >Fragments of Fragments.  These songs could go either way: I could still
> end up loving or hating these songs.
>
> I absolutely *LOVE* Fragments and also Fragments of Fragments.  And, I
> haven't listened to them with headphones yet!

The FoF version has really helped me to open up to the song, oddly enough.

Jim M




More information about the TheWho mailing list