Scoop article

L. Bird pkeets at
Mon Jul 19 13:38:11 CDT 2004

AEB, here ya go.  There are some links, but I'll have to look at those 

Home Music Recording, And The Album That Launched It
Posted by Ed Driscoll on May 13, 2003 12:30 AM (See all posts by Ed 
Filed under: Books: Computers and Internet, Books: Nonfiction, Et Cetera, 
Music: Hard Rock

In 1983, Pete Townshend released a double-album called Scoop, the first of a 
trilogy (plus a best-of set) of releases featuring his home recordings.

Townshend used home recording technology beginning with the first songs he 
wrote for The Who in the mid-1960s. Townshend may have been one of the first 
musicians to actually "write" songs on multi-track recorders and present 
them to his band, rather than simply relying on paper and pencil, or simply 
strumming a guitar and singing. (Townshend can't write music, which made the 
recording process doubly important for him.)

The recordings on the Scoop series are notable for a number of reasons--they 
highlight Townshend's sheer love of music and the recording process, and 
they allow him to release material too different (either stylistically, or 
because it's too light or ephemeral) to appear on any of the Who's albums, 
or his regular solo albums.

As David Fricke wrote in Rolling Stone in 1983,

    Scoop, of course, is more than just a chance to hear gritty pre-Who 
versions of "Magic Bus," "Bargain" and "Behind Blue Eyes." Like Bruce 
Springsteen's stark cassette-recorded Nebraska and Phil Collins' subtle 
integration of home demo tracks on his recent solo LPs, it is a stirring 
celebration of the do-it-yourself ethic, a lesson in how little (tape 
machine, acoustic guitar, a wobbly but intimate vocal) can achieve so much 
(the brief, exquisite 1966 sketch of the glowing ballad "So Sad about Us," 
later cut for the Who's Happy Jack).

    Scoop also provides a panoramic view of Townshend's ambitions as a 
songwriter, from the moody, adolescent clump of the "My Generation"-era 
"Circles" to the epic pleading of Quadrophenia's "Love Reign O'er Me" and 
the 1967 moddish Motown pump of "Politician," one of the album's eighteen 
newly unearthed Townshend originals.

    But what makes this artfully programmed collection of home demo antiques 
and studio curios one of the best Who-related records since Who's Next is 
that it presents a pure, expressive Pete Townshend free of the 
responsibilities of being the Pete Townshend, communing with his muse away 
from his image and the emotional politics of the Who. A pre-Tommy track 
never cut by the band, "Melancholia" captures in his solitary whine and the 
whirlpool sigh of his tape-phasing treatment of the guitars and drums an 
acute solitary sadness that the Who would have turned into an angry punch 

Perhaps most importantly for many Who fans, they show how radically the 
group could transform his songs, as each musician's style was often very 
different than Townshend's natural tendencies. He deliberately kept the bass 
and drum lines very simple, and he sang his early recordings in a much 
higher and less macho-sounding voice than Roger Daltry. Daltry, Keith Moon 
and John Entwistle thus had plenty of room to crack open Townshend's songs 
and deconstruct them (long before that word became part of the postmodern 
lexicon) into music suitable for the Who. Obviously, Townshend knew his 
fellow musicians better than anyone, and wrote for the group's sound. But he 
also knew enough to give them plenty of room to make the material their own.

The Revolution Will Be Recorded

Purely coincidently, Townshend's first Scoop set arrived virtually 
simultaneously with the first affordable four-track cassette recorders from 
companies such as Fostex and Tascam.

What's a four-track cassette recorder? It's not half of the eight-track 
cassette deck that was inside of your 1975 Chevy Nova. It's simply a 
cassette recorder that instead of playing the two stereo tracks on side, 
only plays in one direction, but it allows recording on all four of those 
tracks either individually, or simultaneously.

When they began showing up in the mid-1980s, suddenly, for less than a 
thousand dollars, the average musician had access to multitrack recording 
equipment to write songs or experiment with overdubbing. So a drum machine 
could go on track one, a bass guitar on track two, a rhythm guitar on track 
three, and a lead vocal and guitar solo (when there's no singing) on track 

The Golden Era of Home Recording

While four-track cassette recorders are being produced today, for about the 
same money as a four-track cost in 1983, a PC can be fitted with the 
software and hardware necessary to record virtually unlimited tracks. (Most 
commercial music of the 1970s and 1980s was recorded on 24-track recording 
decks, and 24 tracks is child's play for a program such as Cakewalk's 
Sonar.) The only real limitation is the amount of RAM a computer is 
equipped, and the size of its hard drive. Beyond that, any computer with 
Windows 2000 or XP, and ideally, at least a gigahertz-speed processor can be 
pressed into service as a home recording platform.

The result is a paradoxical time for musicians: while the music industry is 
in the worst slump it's faced since before the dawn of MTV, and the industry 
tries to further crack down on the recording of legally purchased music, 
home recording is experiencing its golden age, as the technology is 
affordable enough, accessible enough, and easy enough to allow any serious 
musician more powerful recording technology than George Martin ever had with 
the Beatles at Abbey Road.

Would You Like To Learn More?

But there is a learning curve to home recording via PC, which I personally 
found to be steep, when I made the jump from the hand-on experience of the 
four-tracks of the 1980s, to the GUIs of today. While most recording 
programs have decent built-in help files, they only go so far, so it helps 
to have some guides for assistance.

Sonar is the flagship home recording program of Cakewalk, a company that has 
been producing recording software for the PC-platform since the late 1980s. 
It's tremendously flexible, but that flexibility comes at a price: it can be 
a fiendishly complex program for the beginner, no matter how much experience 
he had with analog recording.

Fortunately though, Scott R. Garrigus' Sonar Power is real help, explaining 
how the entire program works, and naturally uncovering little known 
features-for it's such a sprawling program that there are bound to be little 
known secrets for anybody using it!

Once I began to get a handle on home multitracking via Sonar, I wanted to 
incorporate synthesizers into its equation. While there are still plenty of 
hardware-based synthesizers, home recording benefits by keeping as much as 
possible inside the computer. But using synthesizers with Sonar was 
problematic for me, probably more so than other PC-based recordists. I've 
always been a guitarist who fiddled with keyboards, and wanted an easy 
solution that still sounded good. I began hearing about a program called 
Reason, produced by a European company called Propellerhead, whose GUI was a 
virtual equipment rack, that several different synthesizers, samplers and 
loop-playing programs could be plugged into and rearranged at will. You 
could even hit a computer key, and flip the rack over, to rearrange virtual 
wires from unit to unit.

Debbie Poyser and Derek Johnson's Users' Guide to Properhead Reason 2is a 
slightly more straightforward book, perhaps because Reason is a simpler 
program than Sonar. There are occasional flashes of political correctness 
("The Reason name comes from a cyberpunk novel called Snow Crash by Neal 
Stephenson. Reason in the novel is the name of a firearm, but we'll pass 
quickly over that!" Right--guns are ever so icky, aren't they?), but clearly 
the emphasis is on learning the program, partially by creating sounds not 
included in the presets, which Poyser and Johnson give several examples of.

Of course, there are a lot more software synthesizers than Reason. And in 
the brand new book, Software Synthesizers, Jim Aikin, the former senior 
editor of Keyboard magazine edits (and contributes a few articles to) a 
broad overview of what's out there.

Scoop Yourself!

Each of these books thoroughly explains what sort of hardware is needed to 
run each program, which these days, as I said above is fairly basic. A PC 
with Windows 2000 or XP, a Soundblaster Audigy card with a LiveDrive bay to 
plug a mic or guitar and these programs is capable of producing astoundingly 
sophisticated recordings.

Which is why I wrote that home recording is in its golden age, and the 
technology is far beyond what was available in the 1970s to Pete Townshend 
when he made the recordings that make up the first Scoop.

Turn on, tune up, and start making some music-all the tools are waiting for 

    Go to for more fine reading, or scroll down to see 
comments on this story and add one of your own. Support by 
shopping at from this page.

Also try partner MusicStack for rare and out-of-print music.

Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today - it's FREE!

More information about the TheWho mailing list