Peer to peer distribution
pkeets at hotmail.com
Thu Jul 15 23:49:17 CDT 2004
Technology - Internet Report
Labels Blacklist Song-Swap Cos, Block Deals-Sources
Thu Jul 15, 4:42 PM ET
Add Technology - Internet Report to My Yahoo!
By Andy Sullivan
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The recording industry has "blacklisted" Internet
file-sharing services and is preventing other companies like RealNetworks
Inc. from doing business with them, according to music and technology
The record labels' attempts to isolate song swapping "peer to peer" networks
like Grokster and Morpheus have blocked deals that could have potentially
brought in millions of dollars in revenues, the sources said, and might
violate antitrust laws.
"If the last names of the CEOs of most major record labels ended in a vowel
they'd be calling this behavior racketeering," said former Grokster
president Wayne Rosso.
Record labels say they are simply refusing to work with companies they
regard as illegal.
Some 9.5 million Internet users log on to peer-to-peer networks each day to
copy music and other material from each others' hard drives.
The recording industry says such unfettered copying has cut into CD sales,
and it has sued both the networks and roughly three thousand of their users
for copyright infringement.
Even as the two sides are locked in litigation, several peer-to-peer firms
have tried to open talks with the industry.
So far, recording companies have shown little interest.
"There is a big difference between exploring a new business model in a
legitimate and open business manner ... and going into business with the
taxicab driver who just ran the red light and hit me," EMI Group Plc (news -
web sites) (EMI.L) Executive Vice President John Rose told the Senate
Commerce Committee last month.
Peer-to-peer firms have also run into a brick wall with other technology
companies that distribute licensed content.
British download service Wippit Ltd. broke off plans to advertise and sell
music on Grokster last year after officials determined that Universal Music
Group would cut them off.
"UMI have expressed concern about our relationship with your company and
even though we are providing you with a legitimate service they will not
license music to Wippit if we have any dealings with your company who they
consider 'pirates'," Wippit CEO Paul Myers wrote Grokster in a May 2003
"We had some opportunities, and unfortunately those opportunities were taken
away from us," Myers told Reuters. He declined to elaborate.
"We have the right and the sense not to do business with people who aim to
profit or otherwise enable the theft of our artists' music," Larry Kenswil,
president of Universal's eLabs division, said in a statement.
Other label officials said privately that their contracts commonly are
written to ensure that their material is not sold alongside illegal or
Also last year, RealNetworks (Nasdaq:RNWK - news) abandoned negotiations to
bundle its music-playing software with Morpheus, a deal that could have
eventually steered Morpheus users to paid content distributed on Real's
"The labels have blacklisted you guys ... which means I'm probably not going
to get much latitude to do anything as far as Rhapsody goes," RealNetworks
general manager Ryc Brownigg said in a phone message to StreamCast Networks
Inc. last September.
Brownigg did not return a call seeking comment, and a RealNetworks
spokeswoman declined to comment.
Two other download services have also declined to work with Morpheus because
of pressure from the labels, StreamCast CEO Michael Weiss (news - web sites)
said, adding that confidentiality agreements prevented him from saying which
The record labels have a right to forbid partners from working with
peer-to-peer companies as long as they do so individually and not as a
group, one antitrust expert said.
"If it's done individually, then I think the question is, 'Is this a
reasonable condition on the contract,' and the answer is yes," said George
Mason University professor Ernest Gellhorn.
But the labels are shooting themselves in the foot by ignoring such a large
audience, said one music-industry executive who declined to be identified.
"If they could get one dollar out of these peer-to-peer users ... that's $10
million in the kitty toward the artists and writers. That's a step forward,
and one song sold is one song not illegally downloaded," the executive said.
Sony Music Entertainment Inc. (6758.T), BMG (BERT.UL) and privately held
Warner Music Group declined to comment.
Is your PC infected? Get a FREE online computer virus scan from McAfee®
More information about the TheWho