Re: Quadrophenia vs. Who's Next

[Rich Niven <RNiven@prudential.com>]

Doug Ciceri wrote:
> 
> I'm a little behind in the digests but have enjoyed reading about the
> so-called "Quad-Who's Next" Argument.  It seems that some people favour the
> drumming on Who's Next and some prefer it on Quadrophenia.  I would only
> like to say that I prefer the drumming on Quadrophenia.  I think that Keith
> does a better job and has a superior performance than on Who's Next.  Since
> there has been all the 'arguing' about this, I am going to take another
> critical listen to both albums.  Oh by the way, JJM (I think it was him)
> stated that Keith was better on WN and believes that his opinion is credible
> because he himself is a drummer.  I myself  am also a drummer and disagree
> with this assessment.  Keith seems better on Quad.  This just goes to show
> the other non-drummer people on the list that all the drummers on this list
> do not see 'eye to eye' and that there is much room for debate.  Anyone else
> have any opinions?
> 
> Bye.
> 
> DCHaving been a drummer myself, I vote for Quad........I